The basic design for a Dangerous Game
Rifle (DGR) was finalized by English gun makers such as Holland and
Holland, Rigby, Jeffrey, et al. before the start of WWI. Drawing on
the experiences of big game hunters in their African colonies and
using the new smokeless propellant, Cordite, these custom gun smiths
could now build relatively light weight rifles that surpassed the
stopping power of the earlier 4 to 10 gauge black powder rifles. In
the last 100 years, metallurgy, gun powder, bullet design and
sighting systems have improved exponentially, but in all that time
the form of the DGR has changed little.
Many experts feel that there is no need to
fix something that “ain’t broke”. I agree that all of the good
ideas need to be retained, but I also think that new technologies
must be implemented into the basic design to enhance its
effectiveness. After all, we don’t drive the same cars or fly the
same airplanes that our fathers and grandfathers did. Rifles are no
different, and there needs to be some thought put into what changes
needs to be incorporated to serve the needs of the modern big game
hunter.
Here are all the design features I would
like to see incorporated into a modern, bolt-action, Dangerous Game
Rifle.
A
proper DGR should be designed to operate anywhere on this planet
from the arctic to the tropics, especially for the dangerous game
hunter who hunts species ranging from polar bears to elephants.
Furthermore, I prefer my plains game
caliber rifles generally be built with these same reliable design
features to aid familiarization of function while under stress and
to enhance muscle memory.
Many American big game hunters need a
rifle that is as rugged and reliable in the arctic as in the
tropics. More American hunters will go to Alaska and Canada than
will ever hunt the Dark Continent but they still need a rifle that
will work in either environment or terrain. I’m sure that someday
we’ll hunt the big game of other oxy-nitrogen atmosphere planets,
but today my motto is: EARTH FIRST, we can hunt the other planets
later, so let’s think about our needs on our own terra firma.
Military weapon designers understand this
need for wide climatic adaptability and it should be in the minds of
manufacturers when thinking about building hunting weapons for the
US market. Even if a hunter seldom ventures out of his home state,
the occasional Rocky Mountain elk hunt can become a life threatening
adventure for the Florida or California hunter not prepared for
blizzard conditions and the accompanying bitter sub-zero
temperatures.
Perhaps my 21st Century DGR is a quest for
the Holy Grail of hunting rifles or I’m tilting at windmills, but I
believe that if I could get every one of the following features
incorporated into one bolt-action rifle, I would not only have the
latest high tech all-around hunting weapon, but, perhaps, the
legendary “perfect rifle”.
A hunting weapon consists of three main
components: the lock, the stock and the barrel. While all are
crucial to accuracy, as hunters we know if your barrel is flawed,
perfection in all else matters naught. With all this in mind, here
is my personal wish list of desirable features I want in a 21st
Century DGR.
There are many elements to consider in a
DGR barrel. These are the ones I consider the most crucial.
The first decision is whether to use a
barrel made of stainless or chrome-moly steel. Yes, I know to a
traditionalist this is a travesty to even think, much less say
...... but in Alaska, despite the best modern lubricants, the
weather is renowned for rusting new rifles in a few days because the
Pacific Ocean’s salt air exacerbates the oxidation process. The
fierce winds blow salt spray miles into the interior and lift it
into the atmosphere to be deposited with the rain on the sides of
the coastal range. Many hunters buy stainless steel guns to avoid
their rifles rusting, however, that could be a serious mistake.
An
interesting comment on the Krieger Barrel’s website warns, “It is
inadvisable to use stainless steel in very cold temperatures; i.e.
below 0 degrees Fahrenheit”. In temperatures below 0 degrees,
stainless steel begins to lose its fatigue resistance, increasing
the risk of the steel failing from the combination of high pressure
cartridges and minimum contour barrels. Lower cartridge pressure
and thicker barrels tend to reduce this problem, but at the end of
the day each hunter must evaluate his cartridge choice, possible
hunting destinations, and make his own decision.
Once you decide which material is best for
your particular use, the next decision is whether to go with button,
hammer forged or cut rifling. The German gunsmith Harald Wolf, a
veteran safari hunter and well known publisher of Hatari Times,
explained to me why the advantages of cut rifling are worth the
extra expense. I always had a hunch that cut rifling was the way to
go, but other than my gut feelings, I had no reliable data to back
up my position.
As someone who owns Douglas, Hart and
Lilja custom barrels, I have no complaints about their accuracy, but
the concept of button or hammer forged rifling always made me worry
about the potential stresses being created in the metal. Button
rifling is made by forcing the rifling from the inside out by a
button in the shape of the rifling through a bore-sized hole, and
the button forms the lands and groves from the inside. Hammer
forging is a process where barrels to shaped from the outside in
using a mandrel that has a reverse image of the rifling formed on
its surface.
Like most of these overly technical
nit-picking arguments, I just dismissed it as a theoretical issue
with no practical negative effects - until I read Harald’s
experiences:
One of my old Ferlach teachers stated that
the very best stress-free barrels are cut-rifled. Back then, I did
not believe it, as we were all brain-washed by the barrel makers and
larger gun factories promoting the superiority of hammer-forged or
button-pressed rifling since WW 2. It was nothing but a marketing
gig because manufacturing the latter only costs a fraction of labor
time-consuming cut-rifling.
Good
quality hammer-forged or button-pressed barrels are O.K. if you
don’t mount tin-soldered banded swivel and sight ramps to it. As
soon as you apply heat (for soldering) the hammer-forged will expand
and the button-pressed shrink at this point. The amount would be
hardly measurable even by the most sophisticated micing devices, but
if you push a soft lead plug down the bore you will notice uneven
friction at the points of soldering - and you will never manage to
solve the problem by bore polishing.
You can only stress-relieve barrels before
soldering barrel bands as the temperature involved is higher than
soldering temperature. Such a barrel might print a superb target
with 3 rounds, but if you shoot a 5 to 10 round target you will
experience the occasional flyer, up to 4” out of target center. What
the gun makers do is simply throw away that spoiled target and shoot
another 3 rounds. If the client is shooting and produces a flyer the
salesman says “You flinched - take another 3 rounds”! Me and a
couple of colleagues re-proved this time and again. The foreman of
barrel making at Denel/RSA confirmed the same verbally to me, when
his boss was not around.”
(MS Outlook, 12/2/2006)
My original DGR was a .416 Remington KS
Custom that was stock from the factory except for the tritium
inserts I installed on the sight bases. It had a Kevlar stock,
stainless steel receiver, and a stainless steel barrel which
featured button rifling.
Manufacturers

Krieger Barrels
2024 Mayfield Road
Richfield, WI 53076
(262) 628-8558

Meprolight
58 Hazait Street
P.O. Box 26
Or-Akiva, 30600 Israel
(972) 4 6244111

Ameriglow
5579B Chamblee Dunwoody Road, Suite 214
Atlanta, Georgia 30338
(770)390-0554

Trijicon
49385 Shafer Avenue
P.O. Box 930059
Wixom, MI 48393 USA
1-800-338-0563
(248) 960-7700

Serengeti Stockworks
2860 Farm to Market Rd
Kalispell, Montana 59901
(406)756-0783

Talley
9183 Old Number Six Hwy.
P.O. Box 369
Santee, SC 29142
(803) 854-5700

Warne
9500 SW Tualatin Road
Tualatin, OR 97062
1-800-683-5590
(503) 657-5590

Robar
21438 North 7th Ave, Suite B
Phoenix, Arizona 85027
(623) 581-2648

Granite Mountain Arms
P.O. Box 72736
Phoenix, AZ 85050
(602) 996-9009

Gottfried Prechtl
Auf der Aue 3
D-69488 Birkenau
Germany
+49 6201 167 88

New England Custom Guns
438 Willow Brook Road
Plainfield, NH 03781
(603) 469-3450 |
I have discussed these barrel materials
and rifling techniques with other shooters and gun smiths, and have
finally decided to use a chrome-moly Kreiger in .416 Remington in my
new DGR project. It is not only cut rifled but also cryogenically
treated. Kreiger takes the raw bar stock down to -3200 Fahrenheit
before machining. Cryogenics, as well as moly-coated bullets, have
become a major source of argument in recent years among barrel
makers, competitive shooters, varmint hunters, and everybody else in
the proverbial “Hot Stove League”.
Both
sides of the cryo issue have trotted out various expert scientists
with exhaustive studies to prove their cases. In the end they have
all agreed to disagree and it has now become a matter of faith.
However, one thing is certain about “cryo”-- it virtually eliminates
stress in metal, thus enabling it to be machined more easily. This
saves wear and tear on equipment, makes tool bits last longer
between sharpening and minimizes equipment downtime.
Another thing not many hunters think about
is rust-proof bores, although it has been a burning topic in
military circles. Many military weapons have chromium coated bores
or Stellite chambers to prevent wear and corrosion from fully
automatic fire and inclement weather.
As far as I know, it was the Japanese who
pioneered chrome plating their rifle bores to keep them from rusting
in the South Pacific. Again, problems with a sea salt atmosphere,
but this time combined with the high temperatures and humidity of
the rain forest similar to many African hunting destinations.
There have been other bore enhancement
technologies over the years, such as Black Star. Most of these were
claims of accuracy enhancement with rust prevention as a happy
bonus. The pros and cons are still being debated among the
brotherhood of benchrest shooters.
A stainless steel barrel in sub-arctic
climates provides all the rust prevention any hunter ever needs.
But, in extremely cold conditions, there is nothing that has proven
better than running an oily patch down the bore of a moly-chrome
steel barrel when you return to camp after each day’s hunting then
following that with a dry patch swab first thing in the morning.
Hunters seldom see rifles with tritium
night sights. Most of the rifles I have seen at the Custom Gun
Guild show in Reno, Nevada rarely feature these innovations,
although I’ve found only a few with a tritium front sight. This is
a serious omission in my experience.
On
my first big bore rifle the first thing I did was to order some
night sights that were marketed for Remington combat shotguns. They
are imported from Israel and are sold in the States as Meprolight
for about $100. These have the usual front sight insert as well as
a two dot insert on the rear sight island. I ordered this setup in
the days before everyone had the Internet, and there weren’t any
forums and few dedicated safari magazines, so you were pretty much
on your own as to what you thought was needed on a DGR.
These Meprolight sights were exactly like
the regular iron sights that came standard on the rifle and I
installed them in 5 minutes or less. With detachable Warne or
Talley rings, I could remove the scope and have an excellent weapon
for around the camp at night. When professional hunters either from
Australia to Africa would shoot my rifle at night, they would
comment about how much they loved those sights and how every rifle
should have tritium iron sights installed out of the box. They are
so unobtrusive that even most diehard traditionalist would not
object. They are hardly noticeable during the day and are priceless
when there are lions and hyenas sulking around outside your tent or
you find yourself walking up a wounded leopard. The only drawback
is that they burn out after 8 or 10 years and must be replaced.
Other than Meprolight, Trijicon, and
Ameriglo, I don’t know of anyone who makes a proper tritium rear
sight. The only peep sights with tritium inserts, that I am aware
of, are those made for the Ameriglo AR15/M-16 sight. The real
innovators here are pistol sight manufacturers who have made them
with different colors to differentiate front from rear, and with
differently shaped inserts to enhance sight picture and alignment.
I am sure there is a custom pistol smith in the States who could
install tritium inserts into a rifle’s rear sights, but I have not
yet located one.
You can get tritium front sights ready to
install on a rifle from Paul Jaeger’s old company, New England
Custom Guns, which is now run by his nephew Dietrich Apel. Dietrich
apprenticed over 50 years ago under his grandfather, Franz Jaeger,
in the house and factory where he grew up before he escaped from
East Germany. Rumor is that one of their “Universal” series sights
has a tritium insert, but there was no mention of it on their
website. Perhaps a closer study of Brownell’s catalogue will turn
up the sight.
Alan
Bunn is a hunting publication veteran with a Bachelor of Arts in
Journalism from the University of Georgia. He hunts
Africa regularly and is an avid hunter with rifle,
pistol, shotgun, and bow. |
In the sidebar is a link to Ameriglo
tritium sights similar to the ones I have on my .416 Remington KS
Safari. The great part about the Remington design is that you can
get tritium REAR sights for their island bases. This fact alone was
the deal closer for me. It is great to have a tritium front sight,
but having tritium rears with it for proper sight alignment has
proven itself for me where it counts—in the bush—after dark.
My next mission is to find a pistol smith
who will install some tritium inserts into a set of Talley peep
sights. If not, then I will have to order Remington rear sight
island bases for my rifle, despite the fact that my eyes are getting
older with the rest of me and peeps would work better. This is a
common problem and something to always consider when recommending
sight options. |